SASentiment Analysis Platformworld wire, filtered

Briefing Desk › HSE

Editorial policy

An editorial policy is a promise a desk makes to its readers about how the work is done, written down so that the promise can be checked. This page sets out the rules that govern selection, tone marking and summarising at this desk — not as an aspiration, but as the standard an editor is held to on an ordinary morning.

Front page: today's reading · Standards: editorial standards · Independence: disclaimer · Privacy: privacy policy

What this policy governs

The policy covers three things: which items the desk keeps, how it marks the tone of a kept item, and how it writes the summary that sits above one. It also covers what happens when the desk gets something wrong. It does not cover the reporting of the newspapers, broadcasters and agencies the desk reads — each of those bodies answers for its own work, and the desk answers only for how it reads and re-tells that work.

The rules below are written to be used rather than admired. Where a rule and an editor's judgement come apart on a busy morning, the rule governs, and the divergence is noted for the next review of this page.

Neutral selection

The desk keeps an item because it belongs to a reader's topic, never because of the name attached to it. A development that is awkward for a well-known body is kept on the same footing as one that flatters it, and a body's standing carries no weight in the decision. Selection is a matter of fit, not of favour.

Three tests are applied to every candidate item:

  • Fit. The item must be about the subject a reader named, not merely near it.
  • Substance. It must carry something new — a decision, a figure, a finding.
  • Restraint. Where nothing new is said, the item is left out, however loud its wording.

No outside body may place an item, and none may remove one. Where a reader believes an item has been kept or dropped for the wrong reason, the desk will say plainly what the reason was.

Topics belong to the reader

A topic set belongs to the reader, not to the desk. The desk may suggest how a subject could be named more sharply, and it may say when a topic is so broad that a briefing would swell uselessly, but the choice stays with the reader. The page on choosing your topics sets out how a set is built and how it can be widened or narrowed at a later date.

A reader may drop a topic, add one, or pause the desk altogether, and the desk will follow the instruction without asking why. The rule here is simply that the reader keeps the last word on the subject of their own reading.

The tone reading rule

A tone reading is set from the wording of the item and nothing else. It is not adjusted to suit a reader, an advertiser, a source or a subject, and it is never softened because a subject is powerful. The reading is arrived at the same way for every item, using the method described on the page about measuring tone in running text.

Where two editors read the same item differently, the difference is treated as ordinary rather than as a fault to be hidden. A tone reading is offered as a view a reader can weigh, not as a fact to be accepted, and the desk would rather show the uncertainty in its own reading than pretend to a precision it does not hold.

Summary and opinion kept apart

The summary above an item reports; it does not argue. It carries the who, the what and the why, drawn from the source, and it adds no judgement of its own. Where the desk wishes to comment, it does so in a separate note clearly marked as the desk's view, never folded into a summary and never left for a reader to infer from a tone reading. The path from a raw headline to that finished summary is walked through on the page about from headline to short summary.

Naming sources plainly

Every kept item names the office or publication it came from, in plain words, and never buries the name in a phrase that would let a reader mistake the desk's summary for original reporting. The summaries are the desk's own writing, and the desk says so; the facts inside them belong to the source, and the desk says that too. A reader should never have to guess whose telling of an item they are reading.

Corrections and revisions

When the desk gets something wrong — a figure misstated, a name attached to the wrong office, a caution lost in the squeeze — the page is corrected and the change is noted beside it, in keeping with the editorial standards notes. A quiet edit that leaves no trace is not allowed here. The desk would rather show a correction in the open than present a page that reads as though it were never wrong.

A correction is made on the strength of the evidence, not the standing of the party who asks for it. Where a request for a change cannot be supported, the desk explains why in a sentence or two and leaves the item as it stands.

Rows of grey cabinets in a records hall under even light
The working rules are kept on the page so that any reader can hold the desk to them.

Independence in practice

The desk is an independent editorial house. It takes no money for placing an item, and it answers to no broadcaster, publisher, agency or platform whose work it reads. That independence is stated in a line at the foot of every page and set out at more length on the disclaimer page; who keeps the desk running is described on about the platform.

Keeping the policy current

This page is reviewed when the desk's work changes in a way the rules do not already cover, and the fresh wording replaces the old when it does. A change is written here in plain language, applied from the day it is published, and named on the page so that a reader can see what moved. Nothing in the policy is left to be inferred from the way the desk happens to work in a given week.

Raising a concern

If a reading of the desk's seems to have broken one of the rules above, write and say which rule and which item. The page of questions from readers shows how such correspondence is handled, and the choices open to a reader about their own details are set out on Do not sell or share my personal information. The privacy policy covers what happens to a note once it reaches the desk.

Briefing Desk
Sentiment Analysis Platform
412 South Tryon Street, Suite 340
Charlotte, NC 28202 · United States

Email: [email protected]
Phone: +1 (704) 555-0139

Sentiment Analysis Platform is an independent editorial service. It is not connected to, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of any broadcaster, publisher, newsroom, agency, or platform named anywhere on this site. Nothing published here is professional advice of any kind.